Has the RBA lost the plot?

The Reserve Bank of Australia's decision to raise interest rates earlier this month led to a massive 8% rally in the Australian dollar against the US dollar over the past two weeks. The Australian dollar has now rallied over 50% since early March, a rally so sharp that it raises very serious questions about the currency's credibility as a reliable asset form. The currency has now seen a combined 100% swing in its valuation (50% each way) against the US dollar over the last 15 months. The Australian economy has weathered the recent recession better than all developed economies, experiencing only a temporary negative dip in GDP. How then does this explain the massive volatility in the country's currency? One thing is does demonstrate to us is that the value of the Australian dollar has very little or nothing to do with the actual performance of the Australian economy and its trade volumes, but more to do with the speculative greed driven by the 'money for nothing' monetary policy of the US Federal Reserve (and the Bank of Japan before it). The loose monetary policy of the US is seeing speculators (many of them major US investment banks) use the dollar as a funding currency to essentially sell the dollar in favour of any liquid asset that is not the US dollar. So while hundreds of thousands of American citizens find themselves being made redundant every month, hundreds of billions of the free money being given to US banks by the Fed, supposedly to stimulate the US economy, is instead being used to speculate against the US dollar and in effect bet against a credible recovery in the US, thereby triggering a rather rapid acceleration in the depletion of the wealth of the US population. The ridiculous price surges being witnessed in commodities and many currencies has absolutely zero to do with the economic principles of demand and supply and everything to do with highly leveraged risk and the unchecked and unregulated transactions of large hedge funds and investment banks.

Many Central Banks continue to misread financial markets, primarily because they have not got a clue how they are operated, let alone regulated. The Reserve Bank of Australia takes the biscuit in terms of universal ignorance and shocking misjudgment. We should not be too surprised though as the RBA is the only central bank in the developed world in recent years that intervened to try to prop up its currency at a time when it was grossly overvalued. That episode might go some way to explaining why Governor Stevens chose to hike interest rates at a time when deflation is more of a concern across the globe than inflation. The RBA have a strong Aussie dollar policy and they are prepared to risk the long-run sustainability of the Australian economy in exchange for attracting short-term funds. The US economy has suffered hugely over the past 2 years of recession and the Fed's ongoing accommodative policy of low interest rates is reflective of an economy in protracted turmoil. The most recent current account report out of the US shows the US current account deficit running at 3% of GDP over the past 12 months. The corresponding report for Australia, where the RBA has just risen interest rates, shows a deficit of 3.9%. The disconnects between the Australian dollar, interest rate policy and harsh economic reality are stark and the RBA's continual misreading of the economic world portrays Governor Stevens as a type of Alice in Wonderland type character.

Let's hope his fable does not have a sorry ending, for the citizens of Oz and all its companies that need to export to the outside world.

Bob - Oct 20

The Elastic Band that is the Dollar

The dollar has fallen dramatically in recent months and it took a leg lower in the past week when increased liquidity after the summer holidays saw investors put their money into higher yielding currencies and metals. Despite the usual garb being published daily about the 'dollar being finished' and US debt spiraling out of control, there are some dangerous extremes developing in financial markets again and all the evidence points to financial markets once more being divorced from economic reality. A sharp reversal is inevitable, with the strength and severity of the reversal likely to be determined by the length of time it takes for markets to meaningfully 'correct' or pull back from these extreme levels. The longer it takes, then the more taut the elastic becomes and the more severe the reversal.

Let us look at the key events that lead me to this conclusion.

1) Gold prices.
Gold has risen sharply in the past 2 weeks, to over $1,000 an ounce for the first time since early 2008. Closer examination shows that this increase is not owing to any physical demand for the commodity but by speculative demand from money managers. Open interest hedge fund positions in gold at present, sees over 98% of hedge fund monies being net long on gold. This is an extraordinary extreme no matter how one looks at it and history tells us biased positions do not last forever and the greater the bias the greater the potential for a fall or collapse. Astute money managers should right now be reducing their exposure to gold for this reason, if for nothing else. Gold has the potential to retreat back to $800 or even less within no time, if some event triggers a sale. Central banks could deliberately bring about this collapse in the gold price, if they chose to do so, and there are several reasons why it might be in their economic interests to do so. Gold is traditionally used as a hedge against inflation but currently the globe has a deflationary problem and present and future US market rates do not hint at any looming inflationary issue for the world's largest economy. Gold prices are completely out of sync with interest rate expectations, which indicates gold prices are greatly inflated at current levels. Be warned!

2) Commodity Currencies.
The economic exaggeration currently reflected in equity prices is also evident in the price of commodity currencies. The Australian and New Zealand dollars are up over 40% against their US counterpart since March. The Canadian dollar is up over 20%. The global recovery story is only in its infancy and currency moves of the order of 40% are nonsensical, particularly for the Aussie and New Zealand dollars which represent economies with pretty dire current account deficits. This currency appreciation is based entirely on market speculation. 90% of non-commercial open interest in the Aussie dollar on September 1st was made up of speculative long positions. This represents an unsustainable extreme. It also demonstrates that Central banks have yet to grasp how speculative financial markets are free to derail competitive currency exchange. Central Banks have learned nothing from the recent market collapse and they continue to watch in silence as leveraged speculation in currencies leadings to a pronounced instability in exchange rate markets. The Australian and New Zealand dollars are due for sizeable corrections sooner or later, with both currencies currently punching well above their real exchange rate values.

3) Japanese Yen
What has been striking about the past 2 months in particular has been the replacement of the Japanese yen as the world's favourite funding currency (i.e. by speculative risk merchants) by the US dollar. What this means is that carry trades (speculative bets on higher yielding currencies) are now carried out using the US dollar (the dollar has a paltry 0-0.25% yield rate). 3 month libor rates currently have the dollar cheaper than the yen as a funding currency for the first time in many years. Carry trades, while attractive in some ways, are also very destructive to international trade competition as a large volume of speculative bets involving the same funding currency has the effect of depreciating the value of that funding currency, sometimes quite considerably. We also know that market scares lead to unwinding events that can result in a very sharp appreciation in the funding currency. We have seen this over many years with the yen and for now the dollar is the favoured vehicle for carry trades. At present almost 80% of open interest in the Japanese yen is net long, a quite remarkable position given we have had almost 6 months of unbroken growth in stock markets and sustained investment in riskier assets. It is safe to assume that the the bulk of the biased positioning in the yen right now is against the US dollar and any eventual return to impartial positioning, will result in a sharp reversal and a significant rise in USD/JPY. It is almost certain that interest rates will rise in the US before Japan and will rise much more quickly, something that will spark major capital flows from yen to dollars. The market will figure this one out eventuality, sooner rather than later, so look out for a sharp rise in USD/JPY before the end of this year.

PPP
What most speculative traders and daily analysts tend to ignore is purchasing power parity. It is almost incredulous that over a period of a few months an Australian can buy 40% more with their money than a US citizen can in US dollar terms. The prior Aussie rally to over 95 US cents can be discounted as that was driven exclusively by an asset bubble that burst last year. The differential standard of living in both the Australian and US jurisdictions has hardly changed in the past 6 months, yet the exchange rate markets that Central Banks have criminally refused to regulate now sees Australian citizens being able to buy 40% more than US citizens thanks to the unchecked greed of hedge fund managers. Of course we know that this is a false exchange rate, but at the same time it presents a fantastic opportunity for Australians to buy up US dollar denominated assets at a huge discount. Much the same can be said for Japanese and European (non-UK) investors. Because of the weak dollar exchange rate, it is an excellent time for Asian Banks to buy US Treasurys. European bonds are grossly over-priced for the Japanese and Chinese because of an inflated euro (which is over 20-25% overvalued) and the safer option in the longer run is to stick to buying US bills (forget what the doomsday merchants claim for the US, because we have learned in the past 2 years that the US is where it matters and that any negative contagion from there is global). Capital flows will eventually flow back into the US because of the gross imbalance in PPP and it will happen in a very significant way, once evidence of sustained economic recovery in the US is firmly established. The euro is currently benefiting in an environment that sees zero to minimal capital investment in the non-speculative 'real' economy,' but it will find itself out of favour when capital flows begin to pick up in earnest, quite simply because it is way too expensive to invest in the Eurozone. Even in good times, Eurozone economic growth is always a laggard behind the US and Asia.

Bob B - Sep 15, 2009

Disorderly Financial Markets

We have entered a very strange world of whiplash-like shifts in currency prices which has made trading a highly dangerous and totally unpredictable game. Over the past week we have seen record drops in many currencies against the dollar and the yen while in the past 2 days we have seen lazarus-like recoveries for the euro, sterling and all of the commodity currencies. The bounce in stock markets over the past 24 hours does not feel real and given the economic fundamentals are deteriorating further, it is also not sustainable. There have been some farcical episodes on the world’s stock markets with the German DAX gaining 11.28% on Tuesday, thanks primarily to some bizarre trading on a sole component, i.e. Volkswagon. Sterling has gained 20 yen since its lows of last Friday, while the UK currency has earned 10 cents against the dollar since yesterday morning. Add to this the Aussie dollar being up 15% against the yen in a day and the Canadian dollar up 8 cents against the dollar in the past 20 hours and you begin to see just how disorderly and ridiculous the world’s financial markets have become. It is almost laughable, except there are some big monetary exposures behind these huge swings which are proving to be very expensive for those holding them. It is simply not worth trying to trade in these conditions, unless traders are using the swings to unwind previously exposed positions. One should not be fooled into thinking that trends are reversing, they are not. The high yielding currencies in particular could get a hammering later in the week, especially against the US currency.

There is much talk about the Japanese authorities intervening in the currency markets, following a G7 meeting of finance ministers at the weekend, when the subject was discussed. We will not know until after the event if intervention has taken place, but such has been the depreciation in the yen since Tuesday morning that it may well be possible that the Bank of Japan came in and used the global stock rally as an opportunity to sell the yen. One fact is unavoidable though and that is that the yen’s recent appreciation owes nothing to speculators forcefully moving the currency, but rather it is the result of a repatriation of funds back to Japan, as investors liquidate assets which were originally taken out using the low-yielding yen as the funding currency. For this reason, intervention could prove to be useless exercise over the long run as essentially what is happening is that the yen is returning to its base value, having been grossly under-valued for years. The Bank of Japan may even move to cut rates on Thursday in an attempt to curb the currency’s appreciation but again the net result might only be some short term respite. The yen will only truly depreciate again when risk aversion levels abate and investors feel confident to once again fund risky assets in emerging markets through the low-interest yen.

Do not trade in these market conditions! If you must, use 1:1 leverage.

Bob B - Oct 29